Roll to DisbelieveRoll to Disbelieve
  • Home
  • Series List
    • 1st-Century Fridays
    • Christianese
    • The Christian’s Guide to Ex-Christians
    • Christian Media
    • Great Evangelical Husband Hunt
    • Handbook for the Recently Deconverted
    • Journey into Hell (series)
    • Unequally Yoked Club (UYC)
  • About
  • The RoE (Rules of Engagement)
  • Community
  • Contact

Captain Cassidy

Captain Cassidy is a Gen-X ex-Christian and writer. She writes about how people engage with science, religion, art, and each other. She lives in Idaho with her husband, Mr. Captain, and their squawky orange tabby cat, Princess Bother Pretty Toes. And at any given time, she is running out of bookcase space.
CHECKMATE, ATHEISTS, o algo | roll to disbelieve
Analyzing Christianity

Tim Keller’s answers to ‘defeater beliefs’ for evangelism are so, so bad

Not long ago, I ran across a Cru handout of Tim Keller’s “Deconstructing Defeater Beliefs: Leading the Secular to Christ.” In it, he details what he calls these defeater beliefs, which he thinks are beliefs that make Christian claims seem less plausible. But his response to them is anything but Read more

By Captain Cassidy, 14 hours10/23/2026 ago
not actually part of this nutritious breakfast | roll to disbelieve
Analyzing Christianity

The Christian myth of Essential Vitamin Jesus

After a new round of people treating belief in Jesus like an essential vitamin every human needs, I want to show you why that’s not true. Faith in Jesus isn’t like Vitamin C. Humans don’t need it like that. Nor can we fail to meet all our emotional needs without Read more

By Captain Cassidy, 5 days10/19/2026 ago
need another bucket for this one | roll to disbelieve
Analyzing Christianity

Why Wheaton College protected a predator for decades

If it’s a day ending in -Y, then we have a new sex abuse scandal erupting out of evangelicalism. This time, it involves Wheaton College—one of the biggest names around in evangelical education—and a former high-ranking admin there named Dennis Massaro. According to various reports, for decades this college protected Read more

By Captain Cassidy, 1 week10/16/2026 ago
Analyzing Christianity

‘A Thief in the Night’ loves fear-based evangelism

Recently, we watched A Thief in the Night. This 1972 movie is one of the original grandmasters of the evangelical Rapture genre. Millions of people have seen it, and many of them were just children. Today, let’s check out its overview and see how hard it pushes fear-based marketing to Read more

By Captain Cassidy, 2 weeks10/12/2026 ago
Analyzing Christianity

The false revival turning into evangelicals’ biggest story in years

Ever since I began tracking evangelicals’ insistence on a Gen Z revival, I’ve noticed how well they avoid any unpleasant jabs from reality about it. But lately, it feels like they’re going overboard in avoiding facts. Something else seems to be going on here besides just yet another evangelical talking Read more

By Captain Cassidy, 3 weeks10/05/2026 ago
shout shout let it all out | roll to disbelieve
Analyzing Christianity

An evangelical with no psychology training gets big mad about real psychology

File this under Fork Found in Drawer: An evangelical with no psychology training or experience publishes an almost-certainly 100% AI-written essay on an evangelical news site about how awful psychology is at really, truly fixing people’s emotional and mental health problems. There’s just something magical about someone in the most Read more

By Captain Cassidy, 3 weeks10/02/2026 ago
speaking can be dangerous sometimes | roll to disbelieve
Analyzing Christianity

Tom Ascol’s evangelical masterclass on dealing with anonymous criticism

Recently, we talked about the downfall of G3 ministries after trying to drag Tom Ascol into a minor sermon-plagiarism scandal. These days, Tom Ascol is one of the biggest voices in the ultra-hardline Old Guard faction of the Southern Baptist Convention (SBC). So it’s extremely important for him to model Read more

By Captain Cassidy, 4 weeks09/25/2026 ago
ding dong the reformed witch is dead | roll to disbelieve
Analyzing Christianity

G3 Ministries has gone bye-bye at last after another Reformed scandal

If someone out there still doesn’t get my delighted obsession with evangelical infighting, this G3 Ministries story ought to do the trick. This popular ministry just closed its doors after an egregious incident involving a mystery brown envelope containing anonymous complaints against someone they knew, someone that they absolutely had Read more

By Captain Cassidy, 1 month09/21/2026 ago
fascism came to america wrapped in a flag and carrying a cross, all right | roll to disbelieve
Analyzing Christianity

Evangelical coward Al Mohler is cozying up to Christian nationalists now

Al Mohler is a big-name Southern Baptist Convention (SBC) leader, and he is also the worst kind of bootlicking worm: He moves to place himself right at optimal licking distance by carefully following the boots. He’s not even subtle about it. In a September 2nd article in Baptist Press, we Read more

By Captain Cassidy, 1 month09/18/2026 ago
it'll take you places you were never meant to be | roll to disbelieve
From Patreon

The evangelical copes of the 2010s that made their decline unfixable

In the 2010s, Christians began noticing that their religion had entered a period of decline. For a while, the hints of it were subtle enough to ignore, so most of them did just that. But eventually, it got too obvious and protracted to do that anymore. Evangelicals in particular evolved Read more

By Captain Cassidy, 1 month09/14/2026 ago

Posts pagination

1 2 … 261 Next

Join the Roll to Disbelieve community!

Yes, I would like to join!

Recent Posts

  • Tim Keller’s answers to ‘defeater beliefs’ for evangelism are so, so bad
  • The Christian myth of Essential Vitamin Jesus
  • Why Wheaton College protected a predator for decades
  • ‘A Thief in the Night’ loves fear-based evangelism
  • The false revival turning into evangelicals’ biggest story in years

Categories

  • Analyzing Christianity
  • Codex Disbelievium
  • From Patreon
  • Gaming
  • History and Science
  • Meta Housekeeping
  • Posts
  • SBC Watching
  • The Games We Play
  • Uncategorized

Find Us in Social Media

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Tumblr
  • Link

Support Roll to Disbelieve

  • Roll to Disbelieve Patreon
  • Site/Forum Donation

Join Our Discord Server!

  • Home
  • Series List
  • About
  • The RoE (Rules of Engagement)
  • Community
  • Contact
Hestia | Developed by ThemeIsle