Roll to DisbelieveRoll to Disbelieve
  • Home
  • Series List
    • 1st-Century Fridays
    • Christianese
    • The Christian’s Guide to Ex-Christians
    • Christian Media
    • Great Evangelical Husband Hunt
    • Handbook for the Recently Deconverted
    • Journey into Hell (series)
    • Unequally Yoked Club (UYC)
  • About
  • The RoE (Rules of Engagement)
  • Community
  • Contact

tradcaths (traditional catholics)

It can never be put back together, not even with veins of gold | roll to disbelieve
Analyzing Christianity

Right-wing Christians mock zingers that are actually valid dealbreakers

Last time we met up, I showed you some popular Christian zingers they attribute to atheists. We talked about how these lists of zingers operate as a form of ingroup performance. Today, though, let’s pivot to one of the lists of zingers themselves. Let’s explore why its strawman “atheist arguments” Read more

By Captain Cassidy, 5 days03/20/2026 ago
they're fighty little fellas ain't they | roll to disbelieve
From Patreon

ZINGERS: Why right-wing Christians can’t stop insulting their enemies

A long time ago, I noticed right-wing Christians’ love for what I called ‘zingers‘: insulting retorts that they think totally own their enemies. Their zingers may mystify their targets, and definitely don’t accomplish what right-wing Christians think they should, but they just can’t stop deploying them. Today, let’s explore this Read more

By Captain Cassidy, 1 week03/16/2026 ago
pomp and grandeur fools the flocks so easily | roll to disbelieve
From Patreon

Why alt-right Zoomers might love performative Christianity

Conservative Christianity is largely performative in nature, and it must be. Conservative Christian leaders ache for their flocks to be transformed by a powerful, consuming faith, but almost nobody in their flocks actually has that, much less gets transformed by it. And they’ve known this for years, although they do Read more

By Captain Cassidy, 2 months01/30/2026 ago
SOUND.. LIGHTS.. ACTION! | roll to disbelieve
Analyzing Christianity

The aesthetics of conservative Christianity for the alt-right

For a couple years now, we’ve been hearing about certain aesthetics adopted by alt-right Gen Z Christians. So today, let’s check out the latest news about the alt-right, then check out why their followers find alt-right flavors of Christianity so appealing—and see what right-wing Christian leaders think about this influx Read more

By Captain Cassidy, 2 months01/26/2026 ago
some people just don't wanna be happy | roll to disbelieve
Analyzing Christianity

‘Practical atheism’ is actually a good thing in Christianity

Over a decade ago, Pope Francis slammed what he called practical atheism. With this phrase, he referred to Christians who don’t focus every single moment of their lives on Christianity, but rather live mostly like normal people. The idea caught on quickly with the right-wing Christ-o-sphere, whose inhabitants to denounce Read more

By Captain Cassidy, 2 months01/23/2026 ago
i'm so glad i'm not catholic anymore | roll to disbelieve
Analyzing Christianity

There’s a new pope—and the tradcaths are furious

Tradcaths, a super-vocal, super-conservative branch of Catholicism, have been extra weird since Pope Francis died. I can see why, too: Most of them converted into Catholicism from extremely conservative hardliner evangelical groups, so they expect Catholicism to work like their old faith—just with extra incense and chanting. Nor do they Read more

By Captain Cassidy, 11 months05/12/2025 ago
Analyzing Christianity

Why Pope Francis just nose-thwacked a dissenting cardinal

Pope Francis finally made a direct attack on one of his major critics in the extremist, hardliner faction of Catholicism—US Cardinal Raymond Burke. The timing is no coincidence. It’s one more indication that the ailing organization is teetering on the brink of schism.

By Captain Cassidy, 2 years12/07/2023 ago
Analyzing Christianity

Nancy Pelosi and Communion: Revealing a rift in Catholicism

Communion is a big deal to Catholics in America. But about a month ago, a Catholic archbishop in America barred Nancy Pelosi from being able to take Communion because of her vocal position on abortion rights. The Vatican clearly didn’t agree with this decision, and she herself clearly didn’t either.

By Captain Cassidy, 4 years06/30/2022 ago

Join the Roll to Disbelieve community!

Yes, I would like to join!

Recent Posts

  • Richard Land laments the impossible defection of a Southern Baptist leader
  • Right-wing Christians mock zingers that are actually valid dealbreakers
  • ZINGERS: Why right-wing Christians can’t stop insulting their enemies
  • Evangelicals now trumpeting the value of ‘costly worship’ (for a reason)
  • Hypocrisy: Why evangelicals create a huge gap between ideals and behavior

Categories

  • Analyzing Christianity
  • Codex Disbelievium
  • From Patreon
  • Gaming
  • History and Science
  • Meta Housekeeping
  • Posts
  • SBC Watching
  • The Games We Play
  • Uncategorized

Find Us in Social Media

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Tumblr
  • Link

Support Roll to Disbelieve

  • Roll to Disbelieve Patreon
  • Site/Forum Donation

Join Our Discord Server!

  • Home
  • Series List
  • About
  • The RoE (Rules of Engagement)
  • Community
  • Contact
Hestia | Developed by ThemeIsle