Last time we met up, I showed you a pastor who wondered why oh why Christians acted like demons aren’t real. The answer to his question would be, of course, because even Christians know, deep down, that everything that happens has a natural cause—even if we don’t know what it is yet. But they can’t just say that. So Christians might act like demons aren’t real, but they also insist that demons could cause real things to happen and occasionally even pursue imaginary solutions to their real problems.

It’s one of the central tragedies of Christianity, this inability of believers to discern the difference between imaginary and real causes for things. It’s also one of the core tensions of modern Christianity. Today, let’s explore it.

(This post and its audio ‘cast first went live on Patreon on 11/13/2026. They’re both available there now. Please support my work—see the end of this writeup for options, and thank you for whatever you decide to do!)

SITUATION REPORT: How to tell if something’s caused by demons, sorta

Last time we met up, we talked about a pastor who wondered why Christians keep acting like demons aren’t real. While researching that topic, I kept running into Christians talking about how to tell if something is caused by demons or real stuff. Notably, Christians have a lot of trouble distinguishing demonic possession/oppression from mental illness. But that’s not the only situation that confuses them.

(Demonic oppression looks, in practice, exactly like whatever you’re imagining as demonic possession, except you can tell an elderly church lady she’s oppressed by demons and not get slapped silly. Technically, it should be impossible for a fervent Christian to be possessed. They’re supposed to be possessed already by Jesus.)

When I noticed that confusion, I got curious about what Christians themselves say about how to tell the difference between demons and natural causes. This distinction technically falls under the Christian concept of the spiritual gift of discernment. As we’ll see shortly, this gift is supposedly an advanced-tier version of the basic gift given to all Christians. All Christians are supposed to sense when something’s good or evil.

But none of them seem to know when demons are causing a specific situation.

Today, we’re going to explore this tension in Christianity between belief and reality.

Case example: Greg Locke, on mental illness and autism being caused by literal demons

Greg Locke, who famously “prophesied” in the lead-up to the 2020 elections that Joe Biden would absolutely never become President, has pivoted from false prophecies to what evangelicals call “deliverance ministry.” In 2023, Church Leaders chronicled his shift in focus. “Deliverance ministry” means magically freeing people from demonic oppression/possession.

He hedges quite a bit when declaring that autism is sometimes demonic. “And to deny that is foolish,” he asserts. “I’m not going to discount the situations where it is demonic, and I’m not going to demonize the situations where it’s not demonic.” He goes on to blame parents’ sorority/fraternity pledges in college (among other things) as a source of their kids’ challenges and mental illnesses.

It’s worth noting he caught a lot of flak in 2022 over his earlier and significantly-firmer declaration that autism was completely always caused by demons. According to that story, Twitter even banned him for spreading misinformation.

Mostly, Locke is unhappy about how “the majority” of churches and Christians in America don’t really believe that demons do anything. And yes, I’m sure he is. He now makes his money casting out imaginary demons.

But not once, not ever in that Church Leaders story does Locke give any objective signs of demonic activity. Mostly, it seems, he tries to ferret out past off-limits behavior. This includes taking a fraternity pledge or messing with Ouija boards or, of course, unapproved sex. Once he has anything like that, he proceeds as if demons are his culprits.

Well, the demon-influenced act like demons are involved. Obviously!

We see a similar approach in a Calvinist essay at Westminster Seminary California’s site. In that essay, the writer earnestly suggests that pastors “diagnose” sufferers by asking them if they “dabble in the occult.” Seeking real help is his third suggestion.

In the more florid end of Catholicism, members are indistinguishable from evangelicals. There, we find much the same categorization. They do deliverance as well. Over at Catholic.com, we find a post explaining how to tell if someone’s problem is natural, demon-influenced, or caused by actual possession. The writer, Jimmy Akin, titled the post “How to Tell if Someone is Possessed,” but at no point does he actually tell us that. In fact, he tells concerned Catholics that in most cases, it doesn’t matter anyway if demons are involved or not. “Just deal with the temptation,” he advises.

There’s no consensus here. Other Christian leaders warn against mistaking demonic activity for natural problems. But they can’t rule it out, either.

On the ground, regular Christians argue among themselves about the causes of trouble. They advise with great urgency that people suffering from serious crises seek real help, not exorcisms. It’s like they know very well that they need to at least acknowledge demons. But they also don’t want to pretend that real help isn’t the solution.

The gift of discernment that all Christians should have, plus the extra-special gift for extra-special Christians

In theory, discernment should help Christians resolve any questions about demonic involvement. They even have two levels of discernment for exactly these questions.

Christians believe Yahweh gives certain favored followers spiritual gifts. Discerning the true nature of things is usually one type of them. The gift’s technical name is “the gift of discerning of spirits,” according to popular site Got Questions. However, their writer also stresses that “any born-again believer who chooses to focus on the Word of God is spiritually discerning.” That description doesn’t mean all Christians, of course. The site is evangelical-focused. So that description really only covers evangelicals themselves. These days, evangelicals tend to think that they’re the literal only Christians who are “born again” and “focus[ed] on the Word of God.”

Obligatory. And don’t get them started on the Catholic Magisterium.

For what it’s worth, that idea tracks somewhat with the Bible. In John 10:27, Jesus assures his followers that “My sheep listen to my voice; I know them, and they follow me.” To most Christians, that means they will always know when Jesus is talking to them. In theory, then, basic discernment means they should also know when demons are present.

But that’s not what we see when we look across Christendom. Despite having copious advice about basic discernment, Christians don’t seem to have very good discernment at all. But they sure like to think they not only have that, but also the advanced version. In fact, Randy Alcorn (who’s come up around here a couple of times) wrote in September 2025 that way too many Christians falsely claim they have advanced discernment!

How to discern demons, sorta

For ordinary believers, they try to match up situations with Bible verses. Or they rely on tribal folklore about demons. (That’s what Locke and that Westminster guy were suggesting, too.) They can’t shy away from demons completely, after all. So instead, they try to balance their belief with the evidence provided by reality.

In 2021, a Redditor shared an essay called “Never the demons” by Samuel D. James. In it, James asserts that since Jesus saw demons everywhere, so too should today’s Christians. Our Redditor sounds very impressed by the essay. He even seems to agree completely with it. But he also writes in a comment, “in actually [sic] practice, the thought of demonic activity/influence almost never crosses my mind.” I’m not even half surprised, either. Of course it doesn’t.

Then, in 2024 another Redditor asked the folks at r/TrueChristian a question. He aimed it squarely at any group members who didn’t believe in demons. He wanted to know why they didn’t. But not one such member replied, if any even existed there. Every single response comes from Christians who fully believe in demons. And their answers only speculated about why fakey-fake fake Christians might not share this belief. So not one person could provide any real Christian answer to demons not existing.

We get more info from a 2020 post from a Christian at the Baptist Board forum. Miss E offers a long list containing objective signs of demonic activity. But not one of them actually sounds supernatural. Even #4, “Supernatural knowledge [. . .] not known by the demonized person,” just sounds like cold reading. She reacts indignantly to other commenters pushing back on her list. The group argues for 8 solid pages about it. Nobody can convince her she’s wrong.

Getting real: Why it’s (almost) always mental/behavioral stuff

Deliverance believers sometimes offer some physical symptoms of demonic activity. Catholics cite super strength as a sign of possession. Miss E suggests levitation. Yes, levitation. (I suspect she’s a Boomer. That was a popular sign of demons back in Doreen Irvine’s day, but I don’t see it cited often nowadays by younger Christians.)

But those phenomena aren’t supernatural. Decades ago, Transcendental Meditation folks famously claimed to be able to levitate. As a writer at Medium explains, it’s just hopping while sitting cross-legged. As for super strength, it sounds exactly like hysterical strength. At times of huge stress, our brains raise the limit of how much our muscles can contract. That temporary increase can cause injuries. But if that burst of wild strength gets us out of mortal danger, that’s a small price to pay.

Generally speaking, the indicators of demonic activity tend to be behavioral, verbal, or mental in nature. The afflictions tend to be related to the same. There’s a reason for that. A Christian who would never try to pray away a toothache will insist that intrusive thoughts must be the whispering of demons. If they can’t see or touch the problem, then that opens the door to imaginary causes for it.

Jesus spends a lot of the Gospels casting out demons. Yes. He does. As one Christian points out, that isn’t a grand sign of demons being real. Nor is it a sign of deliverance ministry being based in reality. No, it’s more like a sign of Jesus being a product of his creators’ time. That’s why he never orders his followers to wash their hands more often. Or to stop keeping slaves.

The writers of the Gospels didn’t know much at all about mental illnesses, so Jesus couldn’t know either. But they also didn’t know much at all about physical ones. Whatever they didn’t understand got categorized as the activity of demons.

Christians today still do that. They just understand more about the world, so demons must creep into smaller and smaller gaps in their understanding.

The results are just “exhausting”

Generally speaking, one finds far more ex-Christians (or at least ex-vangelicals) willing to state the obvious about what happens when Christians must always be primed to consider demons as a source for anything. They say it’s “exhausting.”

Christians with serious mental illnesses also use that exact word, as we see on a 2021 Christian forum discussion. I’m not surprised by that, either. As we’ve seen, the manifestations of their illnesses look exactly like what Greg Locke and the Westminster guy view as absolutely concrete evidence of demons.

When afflicted people have to be on the lookout for imaginary beings, their resources become divided. We only have so much time and emotional fuel to spend. And whether one calls the Christian response to demons deliverance or exorcism, it is a hugely dramatic affair with extremely high expectations regarding both performance and outcomes.

As I said last time, I also found this whole situation to be exhausting. While I was Christian, I developed PTSD (post-traumatic stress disorder). The more dramatic symptoms definitely resemble Christians’ ideas of supernatural influence. So unsurprisingly, my tribemates classified my symptoms as demonic activity or as my discernment of it. As a result, I suffered for years. It took my full deconversion to finally get real help for it. Nothing in Christianity helped me. In fact, my fervor only made my PTSD worse! But real treatment did the trick—and quickly at that.

So when I see a Christian leader like Kris Reece describing my symptoms as demonic oppression/possession, it irks me. If even one other person besides me tries to Jesus their way out of PTSD, that’s too many. And if someone with such a serious illness seeks imaginary help rather than real help, as one bipolar Redditor did once, the results could be absolutely tragic.

But you may rest assured of one thing above all. Even when tragedy results from their efforts, all too many Christians stand ready to classify that as demonic as well.

Please support my work!

Thanks for reading, and thanks for being part of our community! Here are some ways you can support my work:

  • Patreon, of course, for as little as $2 a month! I now write Patreon posts twice a week. They drop on Tuesday and Friday mornings for patrons, then a few days later on the main site, Roll to Disbelieve.
  • Paypal, for direct one-time gifts. To do this, go to paypal.com, then go to the personal tab and say you want to send money, then enter captain_cassidy@yahoo.com (that’s an underscore between the words) as the recipient. It won’t show me your personal information, only whatever email you input.
  • My Amazon affiliate link, for folks who shop at Amazon. Just follow the link, then do your shopping as normal within that same browser window. This link adds nothing to your Amazon bill, but it does send me a little commission for whatever you spend there.

And as always, sharing the links to my work and talking about it! Find us at: Patreon, Rolltodisbelieve.com, Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, Pinterest, Discord (invite: 8pkasaySuD), and now on YouTube!

Visited 147 times, 147 visit(s) today

Captain Cassidy

Captain Cassidy is a Gen-X ex-Christian and writer. She writes about how people engage with science, religion, art, and each other. She lives in Idaho with her husband, Mr. Captain, and their squawky orange tabby cat, Princess Bother Pretty Toes. And at any given time, she is running out of bookcase space.

0 Comments

Leave a Reply

Avatar placeholder

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *