Last month, perennial evangelical gadfly Dinesh D’Souza published yet another book pandering to his aging target audience—this time, about biblical archaeology. It’s a popular topic among literalists in the religion, so the book’s had them chattering of late about it. So today, let me show you one of the more fusty, dowdy elements of modern evangelicalism that younger evangelicals seem to prefer to keep in the past.

(This post and its audio ‘cast first went live on Patreon on 11/20/2026. They’re both available there now. Please support my work—see the end of this writeup for options, and thank you for whatever you decide to do!)

SITUATION REPORT: Get ready, the older evangelicals are yapping about biblical archaeology again

Last month, Dinesh D’Souza published The Stones Cry Out: Biblical Archaeology, Prophecy, and the Last Days. It claims to share objective evidence supporting literalists’ claims about the Bible’s validity as a history book. The work he did on the book appears to have spawned a Prager University video as well (with the same title, viewable here).

This multimedia production has gotten older evangelicals talking again about biblical archaeology. This field involves literalist Christians bastardizing archaeological practices to shoehorn whatever they find into their mythology to PROVE YES PROVE that the Bible is literally true in every single way. By demonstrating this point, they hope to convince outsiders that the Bible also needs to be trusted as an accurate accounting of Yahweh and his demands of humanity—and also to reinforce the faith of existing Christians.

Biblical archaeology belongs solidly to the era that gave us such hits as the Satanic Panic and Rapture predictions. It marks a very serious generational divide in the psyches of evangelicals in particular. Today, I want to introduce you to this aging field of study and check out the Christians who buy into it (and clearly don’t). Then, we’ll explore what it tells us about Christianity today.

First: Everyone, meet Dinesh D’Souza!

Dinesh D’Souza is a right-wing propagandist targeting evangelicals his age and older. Born in 1961 in India, he moved to the United States as a student and naturalized in 1991. He briefly led a Christian school before losing that gig to a sex scandal. In 2014, he also gained a felony conviction for making illegal campaign contributions.

As far as I can tell, he grew up and originally created content as a hardline Catholic. But in 2010, he told Christianity Today that he’s “comfortable with Reformation theology.” That’s an equally hardline flavor of evangelicalism—and its adherents are indistinguishable from hardline Catholics, so D’Souza’s comfort tracks completely. In that same interview, he described himself as a born-again, nondenominational Christian.

But evangelicals think he’s completely one of them. For them, he rose to prominence through his Christian nationalist pandering in 2012. Through various books and movies he made, he propagated and popularized various conspiracy theories related to Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton. His work fully supported Donald Trump and positioned America as the Designated Adult to the entire world. (Unsurprisingly, then, President Donald Trump pardoned him in 2018 for that felony I mentioned a moment ago.)

For years, D’Souza positioned himself as a political and social commentator. With this newest book and video, he now positions himself as someone qualified to discuss a scientific field as well. However, it’s important to note that he has absolutely no training whatsoever in any scientific field.

In summary, he’s about as qualified to talk about archaeology as I am. But I’ll happily tell you that up-front.

For this book and video, he claims he visited Israel in 2022 and became enamored of Jerusalem. In his book’s introduction, he falsely claims that the Judaism practiced in that city, and the language its people speak, is the exact same as it was when the Old Testament was written. (Screengrab of introduction.)

In reality, modern spoken Hebrew is a very recent reconstruction and revival. Until about a century ago, it worked like Latin does today: As a literary language for scholars, not a living, spoken language. And modern Judaism is not OT/NT Judaism at all. One history text used by UC-Irvine describes the Judaism of the Bible as dying with the destruction of the Second Temple in 70 CE.

But you can absolutely trust that the audience D’Souza targets won’t know those details.

An introduction to biblical archaeology

Roughly put, biblical archaeology is the field of study devoted to excavating and interpreting the artifacts of the Levant during the eras described in the Old and New Testaments of the Bible. These eras include the Bronze/Iron Age and the Hellenistic/Classical eras. It holds that the archaeological record of those eras confirms the objective, material accuracy of the Bible’s accounting of history.

This field began in the 1800s, hit its stride after the 1920s, and experienced its heyday in the 1960s. But it remained popular for a few more decades. Wikipedia says that “the model of ‘biblical archaeology’ has collapsed,” which tracks with what I’ve observed in recent decades. The previously-dominant “maximalist” view, which held that Bible verses are true unless proven otherwise, has largely fallen in modern days to the “minimalist” view—which assumes they’re not unless proven otherwise. D’Souza is a maximalist, whether he realizes it or not, and so is his target audience.

All the way to the 1980s or 1990s, fundamentalists in particular loved biblical archaeology. Its ideas went hand in hand with their literalist outlook—literalism being the view that the Bible is completely, literally true in every single detail. (In my work, I usually conflate this view with inerrancy, which holds that the Bible contains absolutely no errors. The two views are slightly different and not always found together. But for our purposes, the distinctions are negligible.)

Back in my college days, my evangelical friends largely considered the findings of biblical archaeology to be childish and over-simplistic. When evangelicalism fused with fundamentalism toward the end of the 1990s, though, evangelicals finally glommed onto those claims.

Nowadays, literalism dominates evangelicalism. So naturally, maximalist biblical archaeology is something evangelicals like. We also find literalist Christians in other flavors of the religion, like hardline Catholicism and some of the weirder, newer offshoots like Mormonism. So instead of referring to biblical archaeology as an evangelical thing, I’ll be talking about it in terms of it being a literalist thing—just as we refer to D’Souza himself as a literalist rather than a Catholic or evangelical. His audience is mainly evangelicals simply because most literalists are evangelicals, that’s all.

Here’s the funny part. Maximalist biblical archaeology is an older Christian’s game. We’ll go into more detail there in a moment.

Why literalist Christians think (maximalist) biblical archaeology is super-important

It used to be just inconceivable that a biblical archaeologist would be anything but a literalist Christian. Now, it’s not hard to find ones who describe themselves, as William Dever does, as “not even a theist”! Of course, these secular biblical archaeologists tend to be minimalist, not maximalist.

But you wouldn’t know that to read and listen to literalist Christians. To them, the field exists to PROVE YES PROVE that their beliefs are objectively factual.

In fact, they need maximalist biblical archaeology to be real and valid. That’s because they’re just like anyone else in the modern age. Their religion might praise those who can maintain faith in the absence of validation from reality, even in the face of contradictory reality, but they personally don’t like that idea. They want to have faith in only that which is objectively real—just like anybody else would.

Theirs is an all-or-nothing system. They can’t have the Exodus be poetic mythmaking. Or King David’s heroics and his soaring reign to be jingoistic, retrofitted alt-history. So when the historical record contradicts the Bible’s stories, that’s an issue. If it turns out that the Bible’s stories are about as invented as Hogwarts and Spider-Man, that calls into question every other belief they hold about Christianity.

But the main dealbreaker with maximalist biblical archaeology

Maximalist biblical archaeologists do not operate like real archaeologists. Their field compares to real archaeology as biblical counseling compares to actual counseling. In both fields, practitioners work top down, not bottom up. Instead, maximalist biblical archaeologists start with the assumption that Levant artifacts from biblical eras confirm the Bible’s accounting of history.

Worse, they tend to consider biblical archaeology an outgrowth of Bible study itself. They conduct research to support their literalist view of the Bible. As minimalist William Dever notes:

From the beginnings of what we call biblical archaeology, perhaps 150 years ago, scholars, mostly western scholars, have attempted to use archaeological data to prove the Bible. And for a long time it was thought to work. [. . .] The truth of the matter today is that archaeology raises more questions about the historicity of the Hebrew Bible and even the New Testament than it provides answers, and that’s very disturbing to some people.

Hector Avalos, an outspoken critic of maximalist biblical archaeology, gave a fantastic presentation in 2011 on just how real archaeology “killed biblical history,” which is the literalist view that the history in the Bible is accurate. If you’re even halfway interested in the topic, his presentation should be on your watch list:

As Avalos describes it, there’s just no room for the Bible’s claims about history in the actual historical record.

And he’s spot on. There’s no way whatsoever that the Old Testament’s books could have been written anytime near the events described. Plenty of cities existed and flourished during the time when the Great Flood should have destroyed them. And the Exodus? What Exodus?

That lack of veracity never ends. Cities destroyed in the Bible’s myths actually got wiped out centuries earlier. Major urban centers actually turn out to be just small settlements. Nobody appears to have thought Israel or its supposedly-epic leaders were a big deal. Monotheism just wasn’t part of early Judaism. Major miracles just aren’t attested in any extant records—when they absolutely should be there. Even the major Jewish figures of the Bible just don’t exist in that record, or they exist but in far smaller scale.

Very occasionally, details in the Bible turn out to be real. It’s no different from what you might expect of an amateur theologian trying to write the definitive Renaissance history of Belgium to bolster their ideas about the Enlightenment. A few details turning out to be real don’t inspire confidence in the entire book being trustworthy.

But Dinesh D’Souza is talking exclusively to an audience that already believes the book is trustworthy. They just need to feel like someone’s done the math there.

The hilarious generational gap between Millennial and Zoomer hardline Christians and the biblical archaeology crowd

You’ll quickly notice, if you look through maximalist biblical archaeology sites and videos, that this is an older Christian’s game. Mostly it’s Boomers and Gen X Christians presenting this stuff and making money from it.

In the media buzz around D’Souza’s new book/video venture, Biola University offered a post from Sean McDowell (Gen X, 50 years old) and Scott Rae (Boomer, 72 years old) titled “How Archaeology Supports the Bible.” In it, they interviewed Paul D. Weaver (probably Gen X, probably about 50) about his own 2026 book Faith Affirming Findings—which is, as you might expect, an example of maximalist biblical archaeology.

I could find no younger Christians talking about either this or D’Souza’s book. Not one. No Millennials, no Zoomers, no Alphas seem to know anything about either D’Souza’s or Weaver’s books. All of the videos and posts praising this work come from sites that cater almost exclusively to older Christians.

I can’t even find any younger Christians commenting on the media posts about these books. Well, unless you count one possible Millennial. He was using D’Souza’s video announcement as a promotion space for himself. That is the literal only younger Christian I found interacting with any discussions online of either D’Souza’s or Weaver’s work.

Generally speaking, it seems like younger Christians focus on different aspects of their religion than PROOF YES PROOF stuff like maximalist biblical archaeology. They’re not interested in the Satanic Panic, or in the notion of demons in rock music, or even in supporting Israel no matter what. They’re not even really old-school Creationist, that I can see, except in the most abstract, bumper-sticker-theology kind of way—that’s been my impression of them for a few years now. The kind of Christianity that gets into all that stuff belongs to previous generations, not to them.

If young literalists even became aware of what a Low Christianity undercurrent their tribal bubble floats atop, I think they’d be more embarrassed than intrigued. But considering how vastly skewed their religion is in terms of age, it’s a solid strategy for boosting retention rates among older believers.

Pseudoscience is a black mark against Christianity

All of them should be embarrassed, not just the young ones.

Augustine of Hippo was an influential Christian bishop who lived between 354-430 CE. At no time more than the present has he been more correct about how devastating pseudoscientists are to his religion’s credibility:

Usually, even a non-Christian knows something about the earth, the heavens, and the other elements of the world, about the motion and orbit of the stars and even their size and relative positions, about the predictable eclipses of the sun and moon, the cycles of the years and the seasons, about the kinds of animals, shrubs, stones, and so forth, and this knowledge he holds to as being certain from reason and experience. Now, it is a disgraceful and dangerous thing for an infidel to hear a Christian, presumably giving the meaning of Holy Scripture, talking nonsense on these topics; and we should take all means to prevent such an embarrassing situation, in which people show up vast ignorance in a Christian and laugh it to scorn.

To Augustine, the problem wasn’t just that the ignorant Christian had spoken foolishly about something heathens knew well, but that heathens might start thinking that this ignorant Christian’s religious sourcebooks might be equally ignorant about spiritual truths too. In fact, he asks that very question regarding heathen perceptions of Christianity’s religious books:

[H]ow are they going to believe those books in matters concerning the resurrection of the dead, the hope of eternal life, and the kingdom of heaven, when they think their pages are full of falsehoods on facts which they themselves have learnt from experience and the light of reason?

What Augustine describes here is the Southern saying: Little lie, big lie. It applies to errors in judgment, too. If Christians can be taken in by a relatively small grifting-source like maximalist biblical archaeology, then what prevents them from being equally mistaken about literalism itself? Or even, dare we imagine, Christianity itself?

The more objectively-untrue things a Christian believes, the less credible their religious claims look. Their judgment already looks iffy enough as it is. That’s why this stuff isn’t aimed at heathens. Heathens already know that maximalist biblical archaeology is a non-starter. This stuff is aimed squarely at people who are already fervent believers. That crowd asks no difficult questions.

The unkindest cut: Even if maximalist biblical archaeology were true, it ultimately wouldn’t matter in the least

But let’s say maximalist biblical archaeologists could actually demonstrate the veracity of the Bible’s claims about history. Let’s say they’re right about the Fall of Jericho. The Exodus, the Great Flood, Creation itself, the enslavement of Jews in Egypt. Sodom and Gomorrah falling to divine judgment. Jesus’ birthplace being a settlement at all in 1 CE, or the existence of him, his family, his disciples, or his followers in the historical record from 1 CE – 33ish CE.

Let’s say they managed that trick. It’s a huge ask—an impossible one on par with them discovering that Paris, France is actually in Siberia. But let’s say.

Even if they managed that trick, it would not demonstrate that the Bible is a valid accounting of a real live god and its demands of humanity.

Finding out Jesus was an actual real human attested in the historical record of his era would not make his claims of divinity more reliable. Nor would it even demonstrate that his miracles were actually real miracles—as we know today, even big ones are very easy to fake!

In 1997, Vancouver, BC residents discovered a Taiwanese UFO cult camping out in their airport. The cultists claimed a little boy with them was “the Jesus of the East.” I keep remembering the boy as the pastor’s son, but I might be wrong. Either way, they had come to Vancouver from their home base in Texas to meet up with “the Jesus of the West,” who they said would be drawn to the airport to meet his counterpart. This cult was real, and so was the little boy. But just saying someone’s “the Jesus of the East” doesn’t mean he actually is. (At the time, I lived in Vancouver. I wrote about the situation here. The whole incident has largely vanished from the web, but here’s a paper talking about it.)

Why, then, should we take seriously a nearly 2000-year-old account saying the same things?

We shouldn’t.

There’s a reason why literalists focus on ancient myths instead of modern evidence

All sorts of things could be true in reality if Christian claims were true. Even if nothing in the Bible at all turned out to be historically accurate, Christians wouldn’t need maximalist biblical archaeology at all if they had any of that.

But they don’t.

I’m talking about the stuff we’d naturally expect to see in a universe containing a real live god who looked like the Bible describes and does what Christians believe:

  • Prayers accomplishing anything outside of the praying person’s head
  • Miracles being real at all and not lies, mistakes, or exaggerations
  • Christians being better people than non-Christians
  • Christians escaping harm and disasters more often than non-Christians do
  • Accurate predictions regarding angels, demons, and Yahweh himself (including prophecies)
  • Christian rules for governing societies, groups, and relationships working better than secular ones
  • Christians themselves being noted for their overwhelming adherence to their own rules
  • More fervent and hardline flavors of Christianity being noted for producing better people, more observant rule-following, and fewer moral failures and scandals

None of that depends in the slightest on the Bible being an accurate history book. And none of it is the case. In fact, the opposite is what we find in every single particular.

The universe works exactly the opposite of what Christians claim. Christianity itself works in the opposite way of what we’d expect of a religion based around a real live god embodying perfect justice and love. And the more fervent and hardline Christians are, the more hypocritical they are.

No, it’s much much easier to focus on ancient myths and try to PROVE YES PROVE they’re true than to look even for half a second at the absolute disgraceful state of literalist Christianity itself. If they can convince Christians of the logical fallacy of bible being accurate -> Christianity making valid claims, then they can hopefully prevent their audience from doubting too much.

Please support my work!

Thanks for reading, and thanks for being part of our community! Here are some ways you can support my work:

  • Patreon, of course, for as little as $2 a month! I now write Patreon posts twice a week. They drop on Tuesday and Friday mornings for patrons, then a few days later on the main site, Roll to Disbelieve.
  • Paypal, for direct one-time gifts. To do this, go to paypal.com, then go to the personal tab and say you want to send money, then enter captain_cassidy@yahoo.com (that’s an underscore between the words) as the recipient. It won’t show me your personal information, only whatever email you input.
  • My Amazon affiliate link, for folks who shop at Amazon. Just follow the link, then do your shopping as normal within that same browser window. This link adds nothing to your Amazon bill, but it does send me a little commission for whatever you spend there.

And as always, sharing the links to my work and talking about it! Find us at: Patreon, Rolltodisbelieve.com, Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, Pinterest, Discord (invite: 8pkasaySuD), and now on YouTube!

Visited 94 times, 94 visit(s) today

Captain Cassidy

Captain Cassidy is a Gen-X ex-Christian and writer. She writes about how people engage with science, religion, art, and each other. She lives in Idaho with her husband, Mr. Captain, and their squawky orange tabby cat, Princess Bother Pretty Toes. And at any given time, she is running out of bookcase space.